Rubric for Performance Assessment System Awards – (27 points possible) Reviewers will multiply the rubric value by the weighting to determine points for each criterion.  The total score is the number of points received for all criteria. This rubric is being used by reviewers to score each application for funding.

 

 

 

 

Rubric Value

1

 

Rubric Value

2

Rubric Value

3

X Weighting

=

Points

 

Action Plan

 

 

Action plan goals and objectives vague

 

Action plan goals and objectives somewhat or partially clear

 

Action plan goals and objectives are clear

 

1

 

 

Action Plan

 

Action plan does not match identified needs and timetable is not reasonable

 

Action plan does not match identified needs OR timetable is unreasonable

 

Action plan matches identified needs and has reasonable timetable

 

1

 

 

 

Project Narrative

 

 

Strengths and limitations of current system not described

 

 

Strengths and limitations of current system not well described

 

Strengths and limitations of current system well described

 

1

 

 

 

Budget requests

 

 

Budget request not supported by narrative

 

 

Budget request not well supported by narrative

 

Budget request well supported by narrative

 

1

 

 

Budget

Requests

 

 

Budget not clearly related to need

 

Budget somewhat or partially related to need

 

Budget clearly related to need

 

2

 

 

Institutional impact

 

Project unlikely to impact current assessment system

 

Project likely to enhance current assessment system

 

Project likely to result in significant improvement in assessment system

 

 

2

 

 

Cross-institutional impact

 

 

No implications for other institutions

 

Some potential impact for other institutions

 

Significant positive impact for multiple institutions

 

1

 

 

 

Total Points _______ Institution ________________________________________Contact Person:_______________________________________

 

Recommendation:     Fund:            ___Yes                      ___No

 

 

            Budget Amount Recommended: _______________

 

Reviewer Comments  (use reverse side if needed):